ICMCTF2008 Session A2: Coatings for Use in Harsh Environments

Thursday, May 1, 2008 1:30 PM in Room Sunrise

Thursday Afternoon

Time Period ThA Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic A Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2008 Schedule

Start Invited? Item
1:30 PM A2-1 Current and Future Research Directions for Coatings Used in Harsh Environments
P.F. Tortorelli (Oak Ridge National Laboratory)

Materials envisioned for application in the harsh high-temperature environments associated with advanced energy systems must show remarkable resistance to chemical degradation or be protected by coatings with this attribute. In either case, the surface layers that develop during exposure in such environments must exhibit long-term stability while acting as an effective permeation barrier to reactive species. The ability to form such stable layers depends on a number of chemical and physical factors as influenced by material parameters, (e.g., composition and structure) as well as by the conditions set by the environment. For coatings, there are additional considerations associated with mechanical and chemical compatibility with the substrate on which they are applied and with the effects of a particular synthesis technique on structure and composition. All these issues will be discussed in terms of corrosion-resistant coating design for extended lifetimes in reactive, high-temperature environments. From this, speculation on concepts for, and routes to, smart and/or highly resistant coatings that rely on present knowledge as well as anticipated advances in our understanding of reaction dynamics and materials behavior under very aggressive environmental conditions will be made.

Work sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy, Division of Materials Sciences and Engineering and Office of Fossil Energy, Advanced Research Materials Program.

2:10 PM A2-3 Protective Coatings Against Metal Dusting
J. Alvarez (ITESM-CCV, Mexico); D. Melo (IPN, Mexico); O. Salas, J. Oseguera (ITESM-CEM, Mexico); V Lopez (IPN, Mexico)
Metal dusting is a corrosion process that occurs in highly carburizing atmospheres. It represents significant economical losses in the petrochemical, iron reduction, and heat treatment industries. In the present work, PVD coatings of protective oxides have been applied to HK40 substrates and their response to metal dusting measured by thermogravimetric analysis. Several chromium oxide coatings were produced by reactive magnetron sputtering under different processing conditions. Thermogravimetric analysis of the coated samples was then carried out in metal dusting conditions. The microstructure of the samples after coating and after metal dusting was analyzed by scanning electron microscopy + energy dispersive analysis and x-ray diffraction. The results indicate that the quality of the coatings, particularly their density, is central for effective protection against metal dusting.
2:30 PM A2-4 Influence of Al on the Carburization Resistance of a Ni Based Alloy Coating
A.S.C.M. D'Oliveira, F.J.R. Cangue (Federal University of Paraná, Brazil)
Carburization and metal dusting are degradation mechanisms involving the diffusion of carbon into a metal alloy and its accumulation on the surface. Crude oil refining expose equipments to these degradation mechanisms as the oil goes through successive heating stages. Coke forms on the internal walls of serpentine pipes of atmosphere and vacuum heaters causing deleterious effects on the equipment efficiency and material service life. Aiming to enhance service life of materials exposed to these aggressive environments this work evaluated the development of a protective coating intend to reduce coke deposition. Mixtures of an atomized Ni alloy (Ni-Mo-Cr) with Al powders up to 15wt% were deposited by Plasma Transferred Arc. Coatings were characterized by visual inspection, X-ray diffraction, Scanning electronic microscopy and Vickers microhardness profiles. Their stability at 650°C and 850°C for 6 hours in an air furnace was compared to that of coatings exposed to pack cementation tests under the same temperatures and soaking times. The good weldability of the original Ni based alloy was not altered by the presence of Al and sound coatings with increasing hardness for the Al modifications were processed. X-ray diffraction results confirmed for the richer Al deposits the development of the NiAl intermetallic compound. Temperature evaluation showed an enhanced stability and resistance to carburization for the coatings processed with 15wt%Al. This behaviour was associated with the development of a protection layer of Al and Cr oxides which creates a barrier to carbon diffusion and to the development intermetallic NiAl phase known to be stable at the tested temperatures.
2:50 PM A2-5 High Temperature Corrosion Resistance of NiAlMo APS-Coating in Chlorine-Based Environments
H. Latreche, M. Schütze (Karl-Winnacker-Institut der Dechema e.V., Germany)

Chlorine gas is widely encountered in chemical industries, as well e.g. as in waste incinerators and plastic/polymer decomposition mills. The corrosion resistance of materials at high temperatures in oxidising atmospheres is usually ensured by the formation of a slow growing protective surface oxide scale. Under chlorine-based atmospheres, the process of scale formation may be considerably affected and the presence of chlorine usually impedes the formation of a long term protective dense oxide scale. A previous study has already been performed in oxidizing-chloridizing atmospheres and has led to the new concept of material quasi-stability diagrams [1- 2]. This study showed that nickel-based alloys offer the best resistance against chlorine attack in general, among the commercial alloys.The quasi-stability diagrams predict that molybdenum should have a positive behaviour in “reducing”-chloridizing atmospheres, whereas aluminium has a positive behaviour in “oxidizing”-chloridizing atmospheres. According to these thermodynamic calculations and first experimental results, several NiAlMo alloys were produced and investigated, and the most successful alloy was selected to be used as a coating for conventional steels against chlorine corrosion. A coating of approximatively 300 µm thickness was thermally sprayed on Armco Iron by means of Atmospheric Plasma Spraying (APS). This work presents the corrosion behaviour of a NiAlMo APS-coating under chlorine-based atmospheres in “reducing”-chloridizing atmospheres and in “oxidising”-chloridizing atmospheres at 800°C. In addition, metallographic characterisation as well as EPMA measurements of the coating cross sections were carried out before and after the corrosion tests. The coating revealed a surprising high resistance against chlorine corrosion which was mainly due to the presence of á-molybdenum phase.

[1] R. Bender, M. Schütze, Mater. Corros., 54 (2003) 567.

[2] R. Bender, M. Schütze, Mater. Corros., 54 (2003) 652.

3:10 PM A2-6 Future Directions in Understanding the Factors that Influence the Life of Advanced High Temperature Materials
D. Shifler (Office Naval Research)

High temperature applications demand materials that have a variety of properties such as high strength, toughness, creep resistance, fatigue resistance, as well as resistance to degradation by their interaction with the environment. All potential metallic materials are unstable in many high temperatures environments without the presence of a protective oxide or coating on the component surface. High temperature alloys derive their resistance to degradation by forming and maintaining a continuous protective oxide surface scale layer that is slow-growing, very stable, and adherent.

Turbine engines for both Naval aircraft and ships are subjected to the corrosive environment of the sea to differing degrees. Higher operating temperatures also are leading to new degradation modes of coatings and materials. Fuel contaminants or the lack of contaminant from alternative synthetic fuels may also strongly influence coatings and materials which can adversely affect the life in these engines. This presentation will dwell on some past results of materials testing and offer some view on future direction into materials research in high temperature materials in aggressive environments.

4:10 PM A2-9 Degradation of APS CoNiCrAlY Bond Coats in Thermal Barrier Coatings by Vanadium, Phosphorus and Sodium Compounds
P. Mohan, T. Patterson (University of Central Florida); V. Desai (New Mexico State University); Y. Sohn (University of Central Florida)
Degradation of air plasma sprayed (APS) free standing CoNiCrAlY metallic bond coats by molten oxides such as V2O5 and P2O5 and a sulfate and vanadate of sodium such as Na2SO4 and NaVO3 in a molten state were investigated at temperatures up to 1000°C. Microstructural development and degradation reactions were examined by using x-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy. Preliminary results revealed that the metallic bond coat was readily dissolved by molten V2O5, which resulted in the subsequent precipitation of (Ni,Co)3(VO4)2 and YVO4 as reaction products. Besides, another study on individual interaction of molten P2O5 with bond coat also evidenced the extensive degradation of bond coat through various reactions resulting in the formation of phosphates such as (Ni,Co)2(PO3)4 and (Cr,Al)(PO3)3. A detailed investigation on various reactions/degradation mechanisms of bond coat by such molten compounds will be presented.
4:30 PM A2-11 Deposition of Nickel-Silver Alloys by Magnetron Sputtering for the Protection of Stainless Steel Parts Against High Technical Corrosive Environments
V. Hody - Le Caër, P. Choquet, H.-N. Migeon (Centre de Recherche Public Gabriel Lippmann, Luxembourg)

The objective of this research project is to improve the corrosion resistance of stainless steel parts to corrosive media (chlorine- and fluorine-based gas) using metallic thin films deposited by Physical Vapour Deposition. In the present work, sputter nickel alloys thin films have been considered to improve the corrosion resistance of stainless steel in fluorinated gas. Silver has been chosen as the alloy element due to its supposed capability to reduce the fluorine diffusion speed in the passive layer of NiF2. Indeed, Atkinson1 carried out a study of the influence of certain doping agents on this diffusion speed by numerical simulation. This study has shown that the smallest monovalent ions such as Li, Na and Ag could obstruct the migration of fluorine in the passive layer. For practical reasons, it has been planed to study the corrosion resistance of Ni-Ag films in fluorinated media. Ni-Ag coatings have then been deposited by co-sputtering in various compositions (Nix-Ag1-x with 0≤x≤1) on stainless steel substrates. The different films have been observed by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and characterized by Energy Dispersive X-ray Analysis (EDX) before and after accelerated corrosion tests in fluorinated medium. Then the corrosion resistance of the coatings has been linked to the coating stoechiometry. The doping concentration of silver into the passive NiF2 layer has also been analyzed by Auger spectroscopy in order to be correlated to the corrosion resistance properties of the Ni-Ag coatings.

1K. Atkinson, PhD - Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, London, 2002.

4:50 PM A2-10 Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy for Characterization of Nano Structured Coatings on -TiAl IN Molten Salts
F.J. Pérez, J.M. Nieto, M.P. Hierro (UCM, Spain)
Molten sulphates are formed in most of the energy production devices, such as gas turbines. There are different attemps in the use of electrochemical techniques in this environments, but the corrosion of the testing samples do not allow to go more than hours of corrosion testing. Based in this problems, and tanking into account the new development of nano-structured coatings for high temperature applications under INNOVATIAL EU project, a new kind of testing sensors with the nano-structured coatings have been develop to monitor their corrosion process in real time. It will allow to know different corrosion mechanism in real time and the expected behaviour in the steady state. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy is the base analysis for this systems, and the development of reference equivalent circuits for the interpretation of results will be explained in detail. Another advantage of this system, is that the corrosion process could be follow, even, if the salts is not yet molten. Another aspects of the corrosion mechanism (effect of protective spinels) will be discusses for further materials design. Based on the monitoring results a new oxidation mechanism will be shown. The results will provide a general overview of the oxidation behaviour of each coating and also a semi-quantitative comparative analysis in real time for different nano-structured coatings on γ-TiAl.
Time Period ThA Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic A Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2008 Schedule