ICMCTF2006 Session E3-3: Fracture, Adhesion, Friction and Wear

Thursday, May 4, 2006 8:30 AM in Room California

Thursday Morning

Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic E Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2006 Schedule

Start Invited? Item
8:30 AM E3-3-1 Adhesion and Fracture of ALD Films and Nanolaminates Under Sliding Contacts
N. Moody, J.M. Jung, T.M. Mayer (Sandia National Laboratories); R.A. Wind, S.M. George (University of Colorado)

Strength, friction, and wear are dominant factors in the performance and reliability of materials and devices fabricated using microsystem technologies. While adequate for some applications, as-fabricated strength and wear properties severely restrict use of these devices in many dynamic applications. Applying coatings and films is one method to enhance device performance and reliability. Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) is a method ideally suited for applying these films as it creates conformal, stress free, and well-adhered films. Of particular interest are ALD tungsten and alumina films where bulk crystalline counterparts exhibit high hardness and good frictional resistance. We have therefore begun a study of ALD tungsten and ALD tungsten and aluminum oxide nanolaminate fracture properties. The tungsten films were deposited to thicknesses ranging from several monolayers to 200 nm on mirror-polished silicon. Nanolaminates were then created from sequential deposition of tungsten and aluminum oxide films in four, eight, and sixteen bi-layer systems to form 100 nm thick films on silicon substrates. Following deposition, the fracture resistance of each film system was measured using nanoscratch techniques at loads characteristic of microsystem operation. The single layer ALD tungsten films exhibited a pronounced susceptibility to channel cracking and delamination while the nanolaminate films exhibited a decrease in fracture susceptibility that varied with bilayer thickness. In this presentation, we will use mechanics based fracture models to show that fracture resistance scales with film structure and bilayer thickness providing a means to tailor wear resistant film performance.

This work was supported by Sandia National Laboratories, a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company for the United States Department of Energy's National Nuclear Security Administration under contract DE-AC04-94AL85000.

8:50 AM E3-3-2 Interface Cracking Behavior of Zinc Coatings on Steel: Experiments and Finite Element Calculations
G.M. Song (Netherlands Institute for Metals Research and Delft University of Technology, Netherlands); W.G. Sloof (Delft University of Technology, Netherlands); Y. Pei, J.T.M. De Hosson (University of Groningen, Netherlands)
Hot-dipping galvanized steels are widely used in automotive industry. The formability and the damage resistance of zinc coatings strongly depend on their microstructure and adhesion on the steel substrate. In order to improve the mechanical performance of zinc coatings, the influence of their thickness, grain orientation, grain size on the zinc coating/ steel substrate interface cracking behavior was studied. To this end, scanning electron microscopic observations during in situ tensile testing of zinc coated high strength TRIP steel sheets were performed. After partial delamination of the zinc coating, cross sections of zinc coated steel were prepared, to determine the location and extend of the interface cracking and the crystallographic orientation of the delaminated zinc grains. Due to the large anisotropy of the mechanical properties of zinc grains, their orientation strongly affects the cracking behavior of the zinc coating/ steel substrate interface. Also the size of the zinc grains, i.e. the lateral dimensions and height corresponding with the coating thickness, significantly determine the interface cracking behavior. A two-grain model using a finite element method is proposed to analyze the zinc coating / steel substrate interface cracking behavior. In addition, the adhesion strength of the zinc coating on steels can be estimated based on this model. Both calculations and experimental observations show that: (i) preferential grain orientation with the 0001 basal plane of zinc parallel to steel surface, (ii) a small grain size and (iii) a small coating thickness mitigate zinc coating / steel substrate interface cracking.
9:10 AM E3-3-3 Gas Barrier Properties and Anomalous Fracture Mechanics of Thin DLC Films Coated on Flexible Polymer Surfaces
A. Hotta, H. Kodama, D. Tsubone, T. Suzuki (Keio University, Japan)
Thin DLC films coated on polymer surfaces are attracting considerable attention due to their wide applications and their interesting surface properties. When DLC films are coated on polymers, the resulting DLC-polymer composites will be highly functionalized materials, some of which presenting dramatically improved gas-barrier properties. In this paper, we will introduce several commonly used polymers such as polyethylene terephthalate (PET) for semi-crystalline polymers, polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) and polystyrene (PS) for amorphous polymers and other synthetic rubbers as well as block copolymers for examples of elastomeric polymers. The gas barrier properties of these DLC-polymer composites were investigated and the fracture mechanics, the chemical structures as well as the adhesion of the DLC-polymer interface were studied and analyzed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Raman spectroscopy and mechanical tensile testing. It was found that some of the DLC-polymer composites dramatically improve their gas barrier properties and that they present anomalous horizontal and vertical micro-cracks and micro-curled surfaces when stretched to a certain strain.
9:30 AM E3-3-4 Adhesion Improvement of Copper (CU) on Carbon (C) by Plasma Treatment and Molybdenum (Mo) Interlayers
C. Eisenmenger-Sittner, B. Schwarz (Vienna University of Technology, Austria); E. Neubauer (ARC Seibersdorf Research, Austria); E. Eiper (Erich Schmid Institute Leoben, Austria); J. Keckes (Materials Center Leoben, Austria)

The thermomechanical properties of C-fiber reinforced Cu-C Metal Matrix Composites which are potential materials for high performance heat sinks depend crucially on wetting and adhesion between the chemically immiscible elements Cu and C. This work presents two approaches to adhesion manipulation: (i) the activation of the C-surface by a treatment in Nitrogen (N2) Radio Frequency (RF) plasma and (ii) the deposition of a Mo-interlayer on the C-surface. Both approaches significantly increase the adhesion of 4 µm thick Cu-coatings deposited by magnetron sputtering immediately after pre treatment. Heat treatment (30 min, 800°C, High Vacuum furnace) leads to a drastic loss in adhesion for the plasma treated samples while the samples containing the Mo-interlayer retain excellent adhesion values. Thermal cycling experiments (RT - 500°C) with X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) measurements of the tensions in the Cu-coating show comparable results: The Cu-coating on the plasma treated sample delaminates after one cycle. The sample with the Mo-interlayer can go through several cycles and is able to sustain thermally induced tensions. The difference in the response of the two sample types to post deposition thermal treatment can be tracked back to the de-wetting behavior of Cu on the different substrates. Void formation is observed at the Cu-C interface in the case of plasma treatment but not for samples with a Mo-interlayer.

This work is supported by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) under grant Nr. P-14534.

9:50 AM E3-3-5 Interface Fracture Energy of Cu/Polyimide Laminate for Flexible Print Circuit - Determination by a New Technique
S. Kamiya, H. Furuta, S. Amaki (Nagoya Institute of Technology, Japan)

Adhesion is one of the fundamental parameters to characterize mechanical strength of thin films on substrates. Quantitative evaluation of adhesive strength of copper thin film on flexible polyimide film, which is used as a flexible print circuit, is tried in this research by using a new technique. Conventional evaluation methods, ex. peel test, have already been developed, and they are simple and easy to perform. However, extraction of information purely on the strength of interface is not so simple because the effect of plastic deformation can be hardly removed from the data obtained with conventional methodssuper[ 1,2].

Kamiya et al.[3] recently developed a new technique to evaluate the toughness of interface, where interface crack was effectively extended by a local load with a minimum amount of plastic deformation in the film and substrate. This technique has already been successfully applied for the case of hard coatings, and its applicability is newly examined in the present study with a combination of softer film and substrate. The specimens were made of the polyimide film, which was diced like a block on the copper film, and loaded parallel to the film surface with a diamond needle until it was scratched off. Interface crack extension process was observed in detail by letting the paint penetrate into the crack during the experiment. The same process was also numerically simulated under the condition of constant energy release rate and compared with the results of experiment. The interface fracture energy of the specimen was determined so that it gives the same simulation result as obtained in the experiment, which was 110 J/m2.

[1] A. K. Moidu, A. N. Sinclair, J. K. Spelt, J. Test. Eval., 26(1998), 247-254.

[2] J. Y. Song, J. Yu, Acta Mater., 50(2002), 3985-3994.

[3] S. Kamiya, H. Nagasawa, K. Yamanobe, M. Saka, Thin Solid Films, 473(2005), 123-131.

10:10 AM E3-3-6 Mechanical Properties of ITO Film Deposited on Polymers Treated by Linear Ion Source
S.-H. Hsiao (Kyoto University, Japan)
Indium oxide doped with tin oxide, ITO, has been extensively used as the transparent conductive electrodes for display industry, and also been utilized on polymer-based film or thin film glass for the applications of flexible display. The polymeric material used in flexible display has its flexibility and lightweight compared to glass-based substrate, however, it seldom match with the requirements in mechanical properties of bending in flexible display. The polymeric material substrate and Inorganic ITO material layer differ significantly in their thermo-mechanical properties: the Young's modulus and coefficient of thermal expansion. Then, the tensile and compressive strain results in the crack failure of ITO thin brittle layer on polymer-based film. The modification of polymeric surface and the deposition of thin film glass as the additional layer between polymers and ITO can be expected to improve its mechanical properties. In this study, a system consists of linear ion source and electron beam evaporation developed in vacuum. The linear ion source treats the polymeric surface while simultaneously the ITO thin film is deposited onto the surface. The tensile strain and adhesion tests demonstrate that polymeric surface modified by linear ion source has been superior adhesive to ITO deposited film. Moreover, linear ion source provides good uniformity of surface treatment and is very suitable for production-scale processing. An additional layer of thin film glass deposited between polymers and ITO is also expected to improve its mechanical properties. An integrated processing with electron-beam evaporation and linear ion source significantly progresses the compatibility of a polymer-based surface, and enhances adhesion quality by enlarge the superficial area to ITO layer.
10:30 AM E3-3-7 Nano And Micro Tribo-Mechanical Testing of Thin Films
N. Gitis, A. Daugela, S. Kuiry, M. Vinogradov (Center for Tribology, Inc.)

Evaluation of mechanical (adhesion to the substrates, hardness and elastic modulus) and tribological (scratch and wear resistance) properties of nano-coatings is important for a high-tech industry.

The present work and its novel technology cover a wide range of thin films on various ceramic and plastic substrates, for example, flat-panel displays, magnetic disks and heads, optical disks and lenses, etc. The following test procedures were used for the comprehensive evaluation of hard-coated metal samples:

- Nano-indentation tests for nano-hardness and elastic modulus evaluation,

- Reciprocating wear tests for evaluation of thin-film friction and durability,

- Scratch-hardness tests under constant load for scratch-resistance and micro-hardness,

- Scratch-adhesion tests under increasing load for thin-film adhesion and toughness.

All the tests were performed on the same tester, re-configured for each type of test within a minute by installing corresponding replaceable modules. The Universal Nano & Micro Tester with multiple sensors (indentation and wear depth, normal and lateral forces, contact electrical resistance, acoustics, temperature) and integrated both atomic force and optical microscopes has been utilized to characterize mechanical properties of thin films, with in-situ monitoring their changes during micro and nano indentation, scratching, reciprocating and other tests.

Clear differences between ductile and brittle films, as well as between different deposition technologies, have been observed. For many films there was an excellent correlation of their nano-hardness with wear and scratch resistance, for some films there was a lower degree of correlation due to either different wear mechanisms or poor adhesion. The multi-sensing technology with in-situ digital optical microscopy and periodic AFM imaging helped discover and understand the differences.

10:50 AM E3-3-8 The Effect of Nitrogen Ion Implantation on the Mechanical and Tribological Properties of Chromium Electroplated by Different Processes
A.R. Salehi, S.J. Bull (University of Newcastle, United Kingdom)
Nitrogen ion implantation has been successfully used to improve the tribological properties of electroplated hard chrome coatings in a number of industrial applications. Hard chrome coatings contain a large number of microcracks caused by contraction due to the decomposition of hydrides during deposition and modern low contraction and pulse reverse plating methods have been developed to reduce the extent of this microcracking. In this study we have investigated the effect of nitrogen ion implantation on the nanoindentation response and sliding wear performance of hard chrome, low contraction chrome and pulse reverse chromium platings. An increase in hardness is observed at low loads due to the formation of chromium nitrides in the implanted layer but at higher loads a softening may be observed due to the decomposition of hydrides which remained at the end of plating during the implantation process. The sliding wear behaviour of the chromium layers against a sapphire sphere in the absence of lubrication is dominated by fatigue processes and is controlled by the density of microcracks and brittle undecomposed hydrides in the coatings. The wear rate and wear lifetime of the implanted layers and the optimum dose for the implantation treatment will be discussed.
11:10 AM E3-3-9 Tribological Behavior of Hafnium Diboride Thin Films
A. Chatterjee, J.E. Gerbi, N. Kumar, S. Jayaraman, A.A. Polycarpou (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign); J.P. Chevalier (Centre d'Etudes de Chimie Mettallurgique, France); J.R. Abelson, P. Bellon (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
Transition metal diborides offer an excellent combination of high hardness, high chemical stability and high thermal conductivity, thus making them attractive materials for superhard coatings. In this work, stoichiometric hafnium diboride films are grown by chemical vapor deposition from the single-source, heteroatom-free precursor Hf(BH4)4 under conditions that afford highly conformal and smooth films (precursor pressure ~ 0.1 mTorr, substrate temperature ~ 275°C). In X-ray diffraction, the as-deposited films are amorphous and films annealed to 700°C are nanocrystalline. The present work relates the nanohardness and wear rate of films tested under dry sliding in air to the chemistry and microstructure that develop in the mechanically mixed layers at the surface of the sliding bodies. Nanoindentation (Berkowitz) tests reveal very high hardness, ranging from 25 GPa for the amorphous phase to 40 GPa for the nanocrystalline phase; these values compare favorably to TiB2 and TiN coatings. Hafnium diboride films of thickness ~ 1 µm deposited on SS304 substrates are subjected to pin-on-disk wear testing against a counter face disc of SS440C. Real-time wear data are compared with wear dimensions obtained from SEM images of the wear scar and from profilometry of the wear track. Both the amorphous and nanocrystalline (annealed) samples show very high wear resistance compared to uncoated samples. For the annealed samples, SEM images show the spontaneous formation of a nanostructured third body on the wear surfaces, and this tribochemical material appears to dramatically improve wear resistance, even after wear depths exceeding the initial coating thickness. The adhesive properties of these coatings are studied by Nanoscratch testing. TEM and STEM, including cross-sectional views, are employed to characterize the microstructure of the worn surfaces, especially the nanostructured third body.
11:30 AM E3-3-10 Behaviour of Shot Peening + WC-Co HVOF Sprayed Coating Under Complex Fretting Wear and Fretting Fatigue Loading Condiitons
K. Kubiak, S. Fouvry (Ecole Centrale de Lyon, France); A.M. Marechal (SNCF, France); J.M. Vernet (Ecole Centrale de Lyon, France)

Numerous studies have shown that the displacement amplitude has a critical impact on the fretting damages, it may promote cracking under small partial slip amplitude and wear under larger gross slip condition. Macroscopic fatigue stressing is classically superimposed to the component promoting a catastrophic propagation of the cracks initially activated by the fretting contact. Hence an optimized surface treatment is requested to display high wear resistance but also good performances against crack nucleation and crack propagation. Unfortunately these different aspects are usually studied separately.

The objective of this work is to shown how combined Fretting Wear (i.e only contact loadings are imposed) and Fretting Fatigue (i.e the contact loadings combined with fatigue stressing) test can provide a global overview of the surface treatment performance against fretting loadings. It is shown that these aspects can be quantified through a single and coherent methodology. Considering a representative pressure field a Fretting Wear analysis was conducted to identify the friction law, next the wear kinetics under gross slip conditions and the contact crack nucleation behaviour under partial slip. Applying similar partial slip fretting conditions, a fretting fatigue analysis has been performed to confirm the crack nucleation and propagation response as well as quantify the crack arrest conditions.

Transposed to a low carbon alloy (30NiCrMo), a duplex surface treatment (shot peening + HVOF WC-Co coating) has been investigated. It is shown and explained how and why this combined surface treatment displays very good compromise against wear and cracking fretting damages.

11:50 AM E3-3-11 Microstructure, Mechanical and Tribological Properties of Cr1-xAlxN Films Deposited by Pulsed Closed Field Unbalanced Magnetron Sputtering (P-CFUBMS)
J. Lin, B. Mishra, J.J Moore (Colorado School of Mines); W.D. Sproul (Reactive Sputtering Consulting, LLC)
Cr1-xAlxN films with various Al contents (0 to 60 mol%) were deposited by pulsed closed field unbalanced magnetron sputtering (P-CFUBMS). The effects of aluminum content on the microstructure, mechanical and tribological properties of the Cr1-xAlxN films have been investigated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), pin-on-disk micro-tribometer, nanoindentation, and 3D profilometer. It was found that the nano-hardnesss and elastic modulus of Cr1-xAlxN films increased with increasing Al contents and reached the highest value of 36GPa and 386.32GPa, respectively, at Al content of 50-60mol%. Addition of Al beyond 60% resulted in a change in crystal structure from B1 cubic to B4 hexagonal phase. The wear resistance improved gradually with the increase of Al in the Cr1-xAlxN films. The steady state coefficient of friction measured against a WC ball for the Cr1-xAlxN films were in the range of 0.3-0.5, and the wear factors were less than 10-7mm3N-1M-1.
12:10 PM E3-3-12 Deposition and Mechanical Properties of Cr-B-N Coatings by Unbalanced Mangetron Sputtering
W.C Moerbe (Colorado School of Mines)
Abstract A range of Cr-B-N thin films were deposited using unbalanced magnetron sputtering from a chromium diboride in a reactive argon-nitrogen atmosphere. The chemistry, structure and properties of the films were investigated using a range of analytical techniques that included XRD, SEM, nano-indentation, micro-tribometry, and DTA. The paper discusses the effect of nitrogen content on the mechanical, tribological and oxidation properties of the Cr-B-N thin films. The mechanical and tribological properties are strongly influenced by the formation of h-BN in the films. Hardness and Young's Modulus decrease as a function of nitrogen content which also affects the coefficient of friction. The effect of varying the amounts of amorphous BN, h-BN and CrB2 on the resulting mechanical and tribological properties are discussed.
Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic E Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2006 Schedule