ICMCTF2015 Session B3: Deposition Technologies and Applications for Diamond-like Coatings

Monday, April 20, 2015 1:30 PM in Room San Diego

Monday Afternoon

Time Period MoA Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic B Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2015 Schedule

Start Invited? Item
1:30 PM B3-1 Influence of the Acetylene Precursor Dilution with Argon on the Microstructure, Mechanical and Tribological Properties of a-C:H Films Deposited by Modified Pulsed-DC PECVD Method
Gil Capote (Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Colombia); Gil Mastrapa (PUC-Rio, Brazil); Vladimir Trava-Airoldi (INPE, Brazil)

Amorphous hydrogenated carbon (a-C:H) films have been grown using different hydrocarbon precursors in order to find the best set of mechanical and tribological proprieties. The addition of noble gases to the hydrocarbon precursor atmosphere is expected to increase the ratio of ion to neutral radicals on the surface of the growing film without changing the H/C ratio of the gas mixture. This is in fact a powerful way to investigate the effect of ion bombardment on the structural arrangement and properties of a-C:H films.

In this work, acetylene (C2H2) was be studied using argon as an inert additional gas, in order to determine the mechanical and tribological properties and microstructure of a-C:H films. The films were deposited employing an asymmetrical bipolar pulsed-DC plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD) system and an active screen that worked as an additional cathode.

The a-C:H films were analyzed according to their microstructure, mechanical, and tribological properties as a function of the amount of argon diluted in the acetylene. The film’s microstructure and the hydrogen contents were probed by means of Raman spectroscopy. The internal stress was determined through measurement of the change in the substrate curvature by means of a profilometer, while nanoindentation experiments allowed to determinate the hardness and the elastic modulus of the film. The friction coefficient and wear resistance of the films were determined using a tribometer, while the adhesion of the films was evaluated via the scratch test. In order to improve the a-C:H films’ adhesion to steel substrates, a thin amorphous silicon interlayer was used.

The results showed that the atmosphere of argon diluted in acetylene induced modifications in the properties of the a-C:H films. Hard, adherent, low-stress, and high wear resistant a-C:H films were deposited on steel substrates using a combination of a modified and asymmetrical bipolar pulsed-DC PECVD system, an active screen as additional cathode, and acetylene-argon atmospheres. The use of an amorphous silicon interlayer improved the a-C:H films’ deposition onto steel substrates. These results suggest that the used methodology represented a step forward for thin film growth by using lower pressure and higher plasma density than the conventional PECVD system and may represent a new and useful alternative for mechanical and tribological applications.

1:50 PM B3-2 Investigation of Corrosion and Adhesion Property of Diamond-like-carbon andNitrogen Doped Diamond –Like- Carbon on Ti-6Al-4V
Santu Bhattacherjee, Qiaoqin Yang (University of Saskatchewan, Canada)
Diamond -like- carbon (DLC) thin films is promising to enhance the durability and service performance of Ti-6Al-4V for engineering application due to DLC’s superior mechanical, chemical and biomedical properties. However, DLC suffers from poor adhesion to Ti alloys because of the high internal stress introduced by ion-bombardment and the large expansion coefficient difference with Ti alloy. In this research, ion beam deposition using an end-hall ion source was used to prepare DLC and N-doped DLC on Ti-6Al-4V alloys and pre-deposition of high density diamond nanoparticles by microwave plasma enhanced chemical vapour deposition was employed to address the adhesion issue. The structure and properties of the obtained samples were characterized by various advanced techniques. The results show that incorporation of diamond nanoparticles can significantly enhance the adhesion and doping of nitrogen reduce internal stress, and thus the corrosion resistance in NaCl solution is significantly improved
2:10 PM B3-3 Diamond-like Amorphous Carbon Layer Deposited by Inductively Coupled Plasma System for Next Generation Dry Etching Hard Mask
SeJun Park, Dohyung Kim, Seungmoo Lee, Jeonghoon Nam, Jaihyung Won (Samsung Electronics, Republic of Korea)
As a feature size of semiconductor decreases, a new hard carbon mask film with the high etching selectivity and high transparency is demanded. An amorphous carbon film with both properties of high etching selectivity and high transparency could not have been accomplished using existing method such as Capacitively Coupled Plasma (CCP) type system. This study shows a successful synthesis of the diamond-like amorphous carbon Layer (DACL) film with high selectivity and high transparency using Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) type plasma system which could control the plasma density and ion impingement energy independently. DACL films were deposited from a mixture of C3H6, He and Ar, using conventional ICP system which is the device fabrication equipment with the 300mm-sized wafer. The substrate was 300mm-sized Si wafer. Raman analysis showed that DACL film contained high ratio of sp3 bonding in the film and the bias power to substrate directly controlled the ratio of sp3 bonding, density of film and k (extinction coefficient) by the change of ion impingement energy. The dry etching selectivity of DACL film was linearly changed with the film density and compared to current carbon hard mask, DACL film enhanced the dry etching selectivity more than 30%.
2:30 PM B3-4 Hardness, Wettability and Electrical Conductivity of Hydrogenated Carbon Coatings Deposited by a Plasma Beam Source
Martin Fenker, Kerstin Petrikowski (fem Forschungsinstitut Edelmetalle & Metallchemie, Germany)
Amorphous hydrogenated carbon (a-C:H) coatings have been deposited by plasma-activated chemical vapor deposition (PACVD) by using a plasma beam source (PBS). The PBS utilizes a capacitively coupled plasma excited by radio-frequency (27,12 MHz). Acetylene (C2H2) is conducted into the PBS as precursor gas. The properties of the a-C:H coatings are changed by varying the C2H2 partial pressure (p(C2H2)) and the substrate temperature (100-500 °C). Increasing the p(C2H2) leads to a decrease of the ion energy of the condensing carbon species. The a-C:H coatings have been deposited onto glass, silicon and stainless steel substrates.

The hardness and density of the coatings was measured by instrumented indentation tests and X-ray reflectivity, respectively. The wettability was acquired by water contact angle measurements. The electrical conductivity was recorded by a four-point-probe. The hydrogen content was analyzed by carrier gas hot extraction method. The hardness was found to decrease with increasing p(C2H2) and at higher substrate temperature and is correlated to the density of the a-C:H coatings. The reason for the reduced hardness with increasing p(C2H2) is the decrease in ion energy. Therefore the generation of sp3 bonded carbon is reduced (less kinetic energy for subplantation) and the number of sp2 bonded carbon is increased. The change of the hydrogen content and the water contact angle is correlated and discussed with respect to the changes of the a-C:H film properties.

2:50 PM B3-5 Development of Si-Containing DLC (DLC-Si) Coatings for Automobile Application
Hiroyuki Mori (Toyota Central R&D Labs., Inc., Japan)

Diamond-like carbon has excellent tribological properties such as high wear resistance and low friction. At present, DLC films are of significant interest for automobile parts, because they possess the potential to reduce the friction coefficient under various sliding conditions. We focused on the silicon-containing DLC (DLC-Si) films produced by the DC-PACVD, and its method features a considerably higher deposition rate, higher throwing power, and lower equipment cost and treatment cost compared to conventional methods such as RF-PACVD and sputtering. Therefore, it has a significant potential for wide applications in various industries including the automobile one.

Furthermore, the DLC-Si films shows tribological properties different from those of the conventional DLC film: i.e., low friction in a poorly lubricated atmosphere like dry, water, fuel, etc. The influence of the silicon content in the DLC-Si films on the friction property of the films was evaluated by a tribological test. In addition, the low friction mechanism of the films was examined by analysis of the wear surface. From the obtained surface analytical results, it was suggested that the DLC-Si films exhibited a low friction property caused by the adsorbed water on Si-OH under the dry sliding condition.

However, DLC-Si films have not been able to be used in many applications due to their weak adhesion to a steel substrate. Thus, we developed the pre-activation surface process prior to the DLC-Si films, which have a strong adhesion to steel substrates. The developed coating process has a significant potential for application in various machine components. This technology can be applied to automobile parts such an engine components and drive parts, as well as machine tool parts, dies and jigs. In this session, I will review the DLC-Si coating technology for an automobile application, and share the latest data about their friction performance in tribological tests.

3:30 PM B3-7 Sputtering-based Routes for High-rate Synthesis of Dense and Hard Amorphous Carbon Thin Films
Asim Aijaz (Uppsala University, Angstrom Laboratory, Sweden); Kostas Sarakinos, Ulf Helmersson (Linköping University, Sweden)

High-rate synthesis of dense and hard amorphous carbon (a-C) thin films using conventional magnetron sputtering based methods such as direct current magnetron sputtering is challenging. This is due to low sputtering yield of C as well as difficulty in generating highly ionized C fluxes which are essential for synthesizing dense and hard a-C structures such as diamond-like carbon (DLC). In this contribution, we present sputtering-based routes for high-rate synthesis of dense and hard a-C thin films using high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS). We compile and implement a strategy for generating highly ionized carbon fluxes using Ne-based HiPIMS discharge that entails energetic electrons as compared to Ar-based HiPIMS discharge facilitating the generation of highly ionized C fluxes as well as a-C thin films with mass densities in the order of 2.8 g/cm3 and film hardness exceeding 40 GPa.

In order to address the issue of low deposition rate, we couple a hydrocarbon gas (acetylene) with Ar- and Ne-based high density discharges generated by HiPIMS based processes. Appropriate control of gas phase composition and energy of the ionized depositing species leads to a route capable of providing ten-fold increase in the deposition rate of a-C film growth compared to Ar-HiPIMS discharge. This is achieved without significant incorporation of H (< 10 %) into the films that exhibit relatively high hardness (> 25 GPa) and mass density (~2.32 g/cm3). Using our experimental data together with Monte-Carlo computer simulations and data from the literature we suggest that: (i) dissociative reactions triggered by the interactions of energetic discharge electrons with hydrocarbon gas molecules is an important additional (to the sputtering cathode) source of film forming species and (ii) film microstructure and film hydrogen content are primarily controlled by interactions of energetic plasma species with surface and sub-surface layers of the growing film. Key words; Diamond-like carbon, HiPIMS, HPPMS, hydrogenated amorphous carbon, ionized PVD
3:50 PM B3-8 Friction and Wear Performance of Multilayered a-C:H:Al Coatings
Laureline Kilman (Oerlikon Sorevi, France); Cédric Jaoul, Maggy Colas, Pascal Tristant, Christelle Dublanche-Tixier, Etienne Laborde (SPCTS, France); Frédéric Meunier (Oerlikon Sorevi, France); Olivier Jarry (Oerlikon Metaplas, Germany)

Hydrogenated amorphous carbon (a-C:H) thin films are among the best coating solutions for the reduction of automotive fuel consumption because of its very good tribological properties. Friction losses are indeed one of the main sources of energetic consumption in an automotive engine. 80 % of friction occurring in the valve train system is only due to the cam-follower contact, representing 20 % of the total losses in the engine. That is why the reduction of friction coefficient in dry and lubricated conditions is still in demand. Quite high values for hardness are also required to withstand the severity of this contact. Nowadays, DLC coatings are a standard and well recognized solution but research development is still necessary to improve the performance’s baseline of standard DLC regarding friction performance without impact on wear resistance.

Many metallic elements have been introduced in the DLC (Diamond-Like Carbon) matrix to modify their tribological properties. In particular, elements which are not able to form carbide phases like Al enable to benefit from doping without altering the matrix properties. Al-DLC films are produced in an industrial coater by a hybrid PECVD - magnetron sputtering process using different power on the Al target to explore various Al/C ratios. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy is performed to determine the chemical composition of the films and the structure is observed by Raman spectroscopy. Then hardness is measured by nanoindentation. Finally, tribological tests are performed with an alternative ball-on-disc tribometer to measure wear resistance and friction coefficient in dry and lubricated conditions.

For a static configuration, a-C:H coatings are doped from 0.5 to 11.5 at. % of Al and compared to a standard pure DLC. Tribological tests in dry conditions show a friction reduction from 0.21 to 0.04 by increasing the Al content to 4.7 at. %. In lubricated conditions, Al containing DLC with more than 2 at. % of Al showed a too low wear resistance to be able to evaluate the friction reduction. In order to overcome this issue and to combine wear resistance with friction decrease, multilayer coatings with non-linear Al content have been designed and evaluated.

4:10 PM B3-9 DLC Coatings with its Unique Properties and its use in Multiple Market Segments
Ton Hurkmans (IHI Ionbond Inc., USA)

Its industrial implementation took a while, but the wide family of Diamond Like Carbon coatings (“DLC”) has found its way in many different markets and applications. The combination of achievable coating properties through different deposition techniques and process settings have led to a wide range of engineered materials. These coatings are typically deposited at very mild processing temperatures, making it applicable to a wide range of substrate materials. Today’s industrial coating machines make the deposition of such DLC materials affordable for many industries and applications. One of the ongoing challenges is to process it cheaper and faster to even further increase the penetration in the market place.

In general the family of amorphous DLC materials is well known for a high hardness, relatively low Young’s modulus, low coefficient of friction, chemical inertness, biocompatibility, semi-conductor properties, IR transparency, wettability behavior, and distinct black and grey colors. The only weak property is the in general low temperature stability. Addition of elements like Si help to increase it, but it is still less stable than mostly known for ceramic hard films.

DLC coatings are rarely deposited as a single layer material. In most cases multi-layer and nano-layer configurations are formed in order to gain extra advantages out of the DLC layers. A common multi-layer approach is to start with a metallic layer in order to achieve sufficient adhesion between the desired DLC coating and the substrate material of choice. Pre- and/or post-processing steps are common in order to get maximum benefits out of the applied DLC materials.

The key feature to the tool industry is the chemical inertness in combination with high hardness. In forming or machining of aluminum based alloys there is much less sticking of the aluminum to either dies or cutting edges. The high intrinsic hardness increases the abrasive wear resistance of Si fillers in the aluminum alloys. Anti-sticking behavior improvements are also seen in processing materials like rubbers and food.

Besides tools to make products, many products are coated themselves with multiple variations of DLC. Depending on the tribo-system in play, specific coating properties are selected to obtain maximum benefits of applying the coatings. DLC coatings have found their way in heavy duty machinery, including aerospace and oil and gas, as well as consumer products. Among consumer goods one can think of cars, motor cycle shocks, golf gear, cutlery, medical devices and implants, and hard disk drives.
4:50 PM B3-11 Thick DLC Deposition by MF-AC PECVD Process
Hiroshi Tamagaki, Junji Haga, Asuka Umeda, Hirotaka Ito (Kobe Steel, Ltd., Japan)
Thick diamond like carbon (DLC) coatings up to 17 microns were deposited by a MF-AC PECVD system. This new deposition system features a unique method to generate plasma for deposition, which applies a mid-frequency AC voltage between substrates divided into two groups that are connected to two outputs of an AC power supply. Because the discharge plasma is held between two groups of substrates, this new configuration results in high rate deposition of hydrogenated DLC coating with long term stabilities so that the relatively thick film can be deposited.

The depositions were carried out at an industrial scale unbalanced magnetron sputtering equipment with 4 sputtering cathodes, 6-axes planetary rotary substrate table and with effective loading space of 450mm in diameter and 600mm in height. After etching and interlayer formation by sputtering, depositions of 2-17micron thick DLC coatings were carried out under 3Pa of acetylene and by applying MF-AC power of 3kW range. The deposition rate for the substrates on 2-fold rotation fixtures under full load conditions was 5-6microns/hr and 2-17microns thick DLC coatings were obtained by adjusting deposition time. The hardness of DLC coatings was almost constant around 20GPa whereas the thickness was varied from 2 to 17microns.

5:10 PM B3-12 Site-selective Coating of Carbon Protective Layer on Sub-micron Trenches Using Plasma CVD
Masaharu Shiratani, Xiao Dong, Kazunori Koga, Naho Itagaki, Hyunwoong Seo (Kyushu University, Japan); Giichiro Uchida (Osaka University, Japan)

Carbon films include plasma polymer films, amorphous carbon films (diamond-like carbon, DLC), CVD diamond films as well as graphite films [1, 2]. DLC is an amorphous network solid, containing a high fraction of carbon sp3 sites, but also sp2 sites and hydrogen. DLC films have attractive properties, such as high mechanical hardness, wear resistance, optical transparency and chemical inertness and hence have widespread applications as protective coatings in several areas such as car parts, micro-electromechanical systems (MEMS) and as magnetic storage disks. Site-selective coating of the carbon protective layer on trenches is one of the concerns to realize coatings on submicron wide trench substrates. So far, we have succeeded in Site-selective coating of Cu films on trench, and have realized sub-conformal, conformal and anisotropic deposition, for which Cu is filled without being deposited on sidewall of trenches, using a H-assisted plasma CVD method [3-6]. We have applied the method to carbon protective layer on trenched substrates in order to control deposition profile [7, 8]. Here we have demonstrated three kinds of deposition profiles of carbon films on substrates with submicron wide trenches using H-assisted plasma CVD of Ar + H2 + C7H8. The three deposition profiles are sub-conformal, conformal and anisotropic deposition, for which carbon is deposited on top and bottom of trenches without being deposited on sidewall of trenches. Experimental deposition profiles are determined by the balance between deposition of carbon containing radicals and etching by H atoms. Irradiation of ions hardens films and hence decreases the etching rate. When the etching rate surpasses the deposition rate of carbon containing radicals, no deposition takes place there. Eventually we have realized site-selective coating, coating on top surface, on bottom surface, on sidewall surface, or combination of them on trenches.

Acknowledgements: Work supported by MEXT, JSPS, and JST.

[1] J. Perrin, et al., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A16, 278 (1998). [2] M. Shiratani, et al., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 2, 505 (2001). [3] M. Shiratani, et al., Sci. Technol. Adv, Matr., 36, 4752 (1997). [4] K. Takenaka, et al., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A22, 1903 (2004). [5] K. Takenaka, et al., Pure Appl. Chem., 77, 391 (2005). [6] K. Takenaka, et al., Thin Solid Films, 506-507, 197 (2006). [7] J. Umetsu, et al., Surf. Coat. Technol., 202, 5659 (2008). [8] X. Dong, et al., J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 518, 012010 (2014).
5:30 PM B3-13 Effects of Normal and Shear Stresses in Rolling and Mixed Mode Contact on the Wear and Delamination of a WC/a-C:H Tribological Coating
Behzad Mahmoudi (The University of Akron, USA); Carl H. Hager (The Timken Company, USA); Gary L. Doll (The University of Akron, USA)
The focus of this research is to ascertain the maximum contact stress that a WC/a-C:H coating can withstand in rolling and mixed mode contact. The specific coating under study is a WC/a-C:H thin film with a microstructure specifically optimized to withstand high stress cycle rolling contact. For example, bearings that utilize this optimized coating on the rolling elements are able to achieve more than 3.5 times more stress cycles than bearings operating with commercially available WC/a-C:H coatings on the rolling elements. To determine the maximum contact stress that the optimized WC/a-C:H coating can withstand in rolling and mixed mode contact, experiments were conducted on various combinations of coated discs and rollers in a three disc on roller tribometer. Contributions of surface roughness, slide to roll ratio, and substrate hardness on coating performance were studied. Observations gleaned from the experimental results include that the coating on an isotropically finished roller can withstand contact stresses as high as 2.5 GPa with no measurable wear or delamination in a pure rolling condition. Roughness of the coated component plays a crucial role in coating wear, coating delamination, and wear on the uncoated counterpart. Nonuniform stress concentrations in coated versus uncoated contacts also affects the proclivity of the coating to delaminate from the substrate. Finally, increasing the slide to roll ratio in the experiments increases the shear stresses in the contact and reduces the maximum normal stresses that the coating can withstand.
Time Period MoA Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic B Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2015 Schedule