ICMCTF2009 Session A2: Coatings for Use in Harsh Environments

Thursday, April 30, 2009 8:00 AM in Room Royal Palm 1-3

Thursday Morning

Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic A Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2009 Schedule

Start Invited? Item
8:00 AM A2-1 Application of PVD Coatings in Food Processing Tools
M. Rostagno, S. Durante (DIAD, Italy); M. Perucca (Clean NT Lab - Environment Park S.p.A., Italy); E.A. Boot, F. Cartasegna (Environmental Park, Italy)
PVD and CVD coatings have been widely used in automotive, aeronautical and mechanical applications for their outstanding wear resistance and hardness. Sectors such as food processing have not yet benefited of these technologies and at present the material used are not standardised in specific way. The corrosion/erosion of the machinery used for food processing it’s not only an economical cost (maintenance, substitution of corroded parts, plant stop), but above all an health and environmental cost. The corroded/eroded materials is transferred into the food during the different processing and, as consequence, it is systematically ingested by the final consumers, with concrete possibilities of accumulation and toxicology effects. A typical example it is the nickel release from inox steels used in bakery sector, that it’s suspected to be responsible for allergies and other pathologies, always more frequent even if the allowed nickel threshold has been continuously lower ed. In the food and biomedical sector a growing caution is dedicated to the use of aluminum: since the end of the last century, the aluminum toxicological and neuro-toxicological effects are under investigation: the iper-alluminemy in the humans has been detected as a possible cause of pathologies such as dialysis deficiency, pulmonary diseases, microcistic anemy (no dependent from iron) and others. At present, the scientific community has strong suspects that aluminum ingestion can be a possible cause of Parkinson and Alzheimer. Application of new materials such as coatings can bring a strong innovation, but up to now these are strictly under the responsibilities of the end users who are called to carry out all the test and characterisations necessary to guarantee the safeness and atoxicity of the material applied. The paper presents the results obtained in the application of PVD coatings in steel components used for processing of food in the fodder production sectors. Demon stration test results are shown together with the coatings characterisation. A significant improvement in wear resistance of the coated components has been achieved with a favourable cost/benefit ratio proved by a detailed economic calculation.
8:20 AM A2-3 Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) Study on Corrosion Performance of CrAlSiN Coated Steels in 3.5 wt.% NaCl Solution
C.H. Lin, J.G. Duh (National Tsing-Hua University, Taiwan)
CrAlSiN coatings with Si content from 0 at.% to 11.5 at.% were deposited on mild steels, 304 stainless steels, and 420 stainless steels by magnetron sputtering. According to the broadened peaks in XRD patterns, effect of grain refinement due to dopped Si was verified in as-deposited coatings. Investigations of electrochemical impedance spectrum (EIS) were carried out in 3.5 wt.% NaCl solution to evaluate corrosion resistance of various coating configurations. Two different corrosion mechanisms were proposed for the CrAlSiN/MS and CrAlSiN/SS configurations. From Nyquist plots, CrAlSiN coatings revealed significant improvements on charge-transferred resistance (Rct) with increasing Si content for those deposited on 304 and 420 stainless steels. These improvements were attributed to the grain refinement effect in CrAlSiN coatings. On the other hand, CrAlSiN coatings deposited on mild steel substrates exhibited no specific trend on Rct in EIS tests. From observation of the pitting holes, inferior Rct were attributed to serious delamination of the CrAlSiN coatings. In this case, adhesion between coatings and mild steels was responsible for the measured Rct rather than the microstructure.
8:40 AM A2-4 A Dry Drilling Process Contribution with Solid Carbide TiAlN + AlCrN Coated Drill
W. Mattes (SENAI-SC, ALVES, Brazil); S. Martins (SOCIESC, Brazil)
For both economic and environmental reasons, strong demand for dry drilling exists in the global market. However, it has been especially difficult to obtain a long tool life and to ensure the high quality of drilled holes when dry drilling Austempered Ductile Iron (ADI). Dry drilling tests were carried out without the use of cutting fluid, ADI 293HB and using a coated carbide drill (diameter=10mm) with Vc=120m/min, f=0.2mm/rev, and drilling depth 30mm. Newly developed very smooth TiAlN + AlCrN coating films were deposited on carbide drills. The cutting force during drilling, chip formation characteristics, and wear resistance of the drill edges were investigated. The specially designed drill flute shape, which created small-size chips, effectively reduced the cutting force. Newly developed very smooth nitride films effectively reduced not only the cutting force but also the amount of the wear at the cutting edge. The qualities of the drilled holes were also investigated. Based on these results, very deep dry drilling of Austempered Ductile Iron was achieved together with a practical tool life. This report describes an investigation of the appropriate drill shape and the influence of the coated films on the dry drilling of Austempered Ductile Iron.
9:00 AM A2-5 High Temperature Corrosion Behaviour of Materials in Heavy-Duty Gas Turbines with Fuel Flexibility
B. Bordenet (Alstom (Switzerland) Ltd., Switzerland)

In stationary gas turbines, hot gas path components are in contact with combustion product gases containing impurities. The materials and coatings will degrade by gaseous attack and by hot corrosion, if corrosive salts can condense. The kind and the extent of corrosion attack are strongly dependent on the type and quantity of corrosive species. These contaminants have their origin in the fuel, the intake air and the injected water, where the fuel is the main source. The contaminants are varying with the different fuel types. From a corrosion perspective two main type of fuels can be differentiated: fuels with a high amount of impurities and cleaner fuels with a low amount of impurities. The ash-bearing fuels such as crude and heavy oil belong to the first group, whereas natural gas and diesel belong to the second group. Other liquid fuels or syngas from coal / biomass gasification can belong to both groups depending on their impurity content, which is determined by the level of fuel cleaning.

The encountered corrosion mechanism will be described in dependence of the chemical composition and the quantity of the contaminants. The different types of corrosion attack are illustrated by micrographs from ex-service components and from laboratory samples.

To minimise the hot corrosion damages, process- and material-related countermeasures are proposed for the different fuels. The process-related solutions are described shortly and their impact on the gas turbine operation will be evaluated. Their main goal is the change of the corrosive environment through fuel treatment or use of additives. The other option is the use of higher corrosion-resistant materials and coatings in the hot gas path. An overview of the typical gas turbine materials will be given with respect to their corrosion performance. The focus will be put on the behaviour of metallic overlay coatings and thermal barrier coatings in corrosive environment. Consequences will be discussed for the use of corrosion-resistant systems in new power plants with low CO2 emissions.

9:40 AM A2-7 Diffusion Coatings for Oxidizing High-Chlorine Environments at Elevated Temperatures
B. Rammer, T. Weber, M. Schütze (DECHEMA e.V., Germany)

The presented work aims to find material solutions for a recently developed process that allows the recovery of Phosphorus, an essential plant nutrient and therefore integral component of many fertilizers, from sewage sludge ashes. The process offers the possibility to overcome the previsible shortage of Phosphorus as a natural resource. It is distinguished by the use of highly chlorine-containing atmospheres at temperatures up to 1000°C. Unfortunately, there are currently no materials commercially available that can withstand such conditions over longer periods of time.

For the development of a sufficiently resistant material system, nickel base alloys were chosen as a base material. They feature outstanding high temperature corrosion resistance and strength. To further advance these qualities, protective diffusion coatings, applied by pack cementation, were developed. The thermodynamic assessment of different coating elements revealed that aluminum and silicon have the best prerequisites to form and maintain slow-growing, stable oxide layers with the highest potential for being protective against corrosive attacks.

The performance of the coated materials was examined in long-term tests under simulated field conditions at high temperatures and under atmospheres of up to 10% Cl2 in air. In the paper the theoretical considerations with regards to coating design and results of these experiments will be presented and discussed.

10:00 AM A2-10 Production, Characterization and Evaluation of Protective Cr Oxide Coatings Against Metal Dusting
D. Melo (IPN, Mexico); D. Singüenza, O. Salas (ITESM-CEM, Mexico); R. Reichelt (Wilhelms-Universitaet, Germany); J. Oseguera (ITESM-CEM, Mexico); . López (IPN, Mexico)
Cr oxide/Cr films have been deposited on HK40 steel substrates in order to evaluate their behavior under metal dusting conditions. The films were produced by reactive magnetron sputtering under various conditions of oxygen flow, work pressure, power and bias voltage to find the optimum deposition conditions to form an adequate dense structure with good adhesion to the substrate. The coatings were extensively characterized by scanning electron microscopy, x-ray diffraction and atomic force microscopy. The most promising structures were subjected to metal dusting conditions in a thermobalance to evaluate their response to this type of corrosion.
10:20 AM A2-9 Factors Affecting the Performance of a Porous, High Temperature Abradable Coating
D. Allen (Siemens Energy)
In today’s advanced industrial gas turbines, clearance control is of great importance for reducing fuel consumption and decreasing emissions. Clearance control methods such as abradable coatings are commonly employed on the compressor and turbine sections of these engines. Much of the development work to date on these coatings has been based upon empirical data (rub tests) but it would be beneficial to have some a priori basis for predicting the wear performance of these coatings. To this end we have run a directed series of tests, using a design of experiments (DOE) approach, to elucidate the impact of various coating characteristics on abradability.
10:40 AM A2-12 An Overview of Sulzer Metco Abradable Coatings and Some New Developments in Blade Tipping
S. Wilson (Sulzer Metco, Switzerland); D. Sporer (Sulzer Metco Europe); M. Dorfman (Sulzer Metco, USA)

Thermally sprayed abradable seals are employed in turbomachinery to reduce leakage gaps between stationary and rotating parts to improve efficiency and stall margin. These seals are commonly composite type coatings which derive their abradability from the use of low shear strength materials or from a porous, friable coating structure. The development of mostly zirconia based thermal shock resistant ceramics for use at high temperatures, allowed for abradable seals for the high pressure turbine stages to be developed. On stages with reduced temperatures, both ceramic and metallic coatings of the MCrAlY type can be used.

This paper reviews the state of the art in compressor and turbine clearance control materials and systems, with a focus on novel thermally sprayed ceramic turbine seals with encouraging property combinations which are achieved by the introduction of alternative stabilizers. Normally ceramic seal surfaces require hard tipping of the rotor blades to allow them to cut properly and recent silicon carbide hard tipping technology will be presented.

11:00 AM A2-8 Microstructure and Cutting Mechanics in Abradable Seal Coatings
S. Goergen (Cranfield University, United Kingdom); C. Sellars (Rolls Royce Plc, United Kingdom); I. Walton, D.J. Stephenson, J.R. Nicholls (Cranfield University, United Kingdom)

It is widely recognised that a good abradable coating can significantly improve the efficiency of a gas turbine engine, with correct design allowing blade wear to be minimised. Thus my understanding the abradable process, its link to abradable coating microstructure and the underlying cutting mechanics, it is possible to optimise coating properties.

In this study, metallographic characterisation of abraded coatings has been carried out for three different blade tip/coating systems. Based on this understanding, a micro-cutting model has been constructed to predict abradable behaviour.

It is demonstrated that for a given abradable system coating performance is highly dependent on parameters that define the abradable process, particularly blade tip velocity and incursion rate, and their interaction with the abradable coating microstructure/properties. Based on this modelling work guidelines are given to aid the optimisation of abradable coatings.

11:20 AM A2-11 Degradation of Hot-Dip Aluminized Coating on the Cyclic Oxidation of the Ferritic 430 Stainless Steel
M. Badaruddin, C.J. Wang (National Taiwan University of Science and Technology (NTUST), Taiwan)
The 430 stainless steel was coated by hot-dip in a molten pure aluminum bath. The high temperature oxidation of aluminized stainless steel was studied at 800°C in static air. After oxidation for 20 h, the intermetallic layer consists of three major phases (FeAl 2, FeAl and (Fe2Cr)Al), while the Fe2Al5 phase forms a thin layer in the outer. The intermetallic layer between the Fe2Al5 and FeAl2 contains with many Cr5Al8 precipitates. At the exposure time 120 h, in the outer layer the remain phase of FeAl2 containing many voids and cavities severely suffers the degradation by causing spallation and cracking an oxide layers. However, the beneath phase of FeAl provides a good performance in protecting the metal during oxidation attacking. A protective oxide formed on the surface is affected by the properties of intermetalic layer.
Time Period ThM Sessions | Abstract Timeline | Topic A Sessions | Time Periods | Topics | ICMCTF2009 Schedule